Great Minds Think Alike, Or Do They?

You're in a meeting, brainstorming session, or even just chatting with a friend, and someone voices an idea that was just forming in your own head. Almost instinctively, you exclaim, great minds think alike!

It feels good, a little pat on the back for shared brilliance. But what if this widely used proverb isn't quite as straightforward as we assume?

What Defines A Great Mind?

In essence, a great mind isn't just about what someone knows, but how they think, how they learn, how they approach challenges, and what they ultimately contribute to the world. It's a dynamic combination of intelligence, character, and continuous engagement with the world of ideas.

The popular understanding of great minds think alike is simple. Intelligent people often arrive at the same conclusions or ideas independently. It's a celebratory phrase, a nod to intellectual synchronicity. In many contexts, it serves its purpose perfectly well as a lighthearted affirmation.

However, like many ancient sayings, this proverb has a lesser-known, more nuanced, and arguably more profound original form. The full, traditional saying is great minds think alike, but fools seldom differ.

This longer version completely shifts the meaning. It suggests that while intelligent individuals might indeed converge on similar innovative or effective solutions (the great minds part), there's another, less flattering kind of agreement: that of fools who seldom differ.

What does this imply?

When brilliant individuals arrive at the same conclusion, it's often through independent critical thinking, logical deduction, and a deep understanding of the problem at hand. Their agreement is a testament to the validity and robustness of the idea, reached through individual intellectual rigor.

Here's an example ....

Great Minds ~ Imagine two renowned physicists, working independently in different parts of the world, both proposing a similar theoretical framework to explain a complex phenomenon. Their shared conclusion isn't due to a lack of individual thought, but rather a convergence on the most logical and evidence-based explanation.

Fools Seldom Differ ~ This part of the proverb serves as a crucial counterpoint. It warns against uncritical agreement, herd mentality, or a lack of independent thought. When those who are less discerning or less inclined to think deeply agree, it might not be a sign of collective genius, but rather a symptom of conformity, ignorance, or a failure to challenge assumptions.

Consider a group project where one person dominates the discussion, and everyone else simply nods along without questioning or offering alternative perspectives, even if the proposed plan has obvious flaws.

Their agreement isn't a sign of shared brilliance, but a lack of individual critical engagement. Or, think of a widespread misconception that persists because people don't bother to research or challenge it, simply accepting what everyone else seems to believe.

Why Does This Matter?

Understanding the full proverb encourages us to be more discerning about agreement. It prompts us to ask ....

Is this agreement a result of independent, rigorous thought from multiple perspectives? Or is it a sign of groupthink, a lack of critical analysis, or simply following the easiest path? 

Next time you hear or say great minds think alike, take a moment to consider the context.

Is it truly a moment of shared intellectual breakthrough, or is there a subtle warning hidden within the unspoken second half of the proverb?

It's a reminder that true intelligence often involves not just arriving at good ideas, but the courage to question, challenge, and think independently, even when it means differing from the crowd.

                            -------------------------

• If you live and work in Israel, English For Israel is here for you, offering

• Business English tuition

• Development of self-confidence when speaking English

• Professional English CVs

• Read my references

• Telephone 053 7120720

• Email: englishforisrael770@gmail.com